BEST PELLET STOVE 2017 | BUYER’S GUIDE

The ultimate review of pellet stoves

Energy prices keep on changing every year, and they never go down, it is becoming difficult for an average family to pay their bills. You are constantly trying to save up, so you have enough money to pay your energy bills. People want to look for alternatives to heat their homes. Best Pellet stoves can be your best alternative and can significantly reduce your energy bills. And what’s better, if you decide to use pellet stoves as your primary source for heating your home, you might not need to pay any energy bills at all.

best pellet stove reviews in 2017

best pellet stove reviews

Top Pellet Stoves List

  • Castle Serenity Wood Pellet Stove
  • Pleasant Hearth Cabinet Style Pellet Stove
  • ​Comfortbilt Pellet Stove HP22
  • ​US Stove R5824 Pellet Stove
  • ​Pelpro Pellet Stove
  • Pleasant Hearth Medium Pellet Stove with 40-Pound Hopper

I hope most of you will agree with me when I say; pellet stoves have become a necessity these days. In the ancient times, wood stoves were this large ugly looking stoves which had a burning pot center. Wood was thrown into this pot, and it would burn giving out heat which was used to keep the houses warm and cozy.

In today’s world, pellet stoves have replaced the wood ones. They are trendier and burn tiny recycled pellets made of corn, walnut or peanut shells, wood shavings or sawdust. The pellets are eco-friendly as they are made from compressed biomass waste materials. And you are burning these waste materials to generate heat. So, you are doing nature a favor! It’s a win-win. Pellets turn waste materials into energy, which would otherwise be dumped as landfill. And in this way, we avoid using fuel as well.

The best stove pellets are modern and sleek to look at and are no less than a piece of art in your home! You can buy the best pellet stove online these days. You don’t even need to go out and search for them. And the fun part is they will get delivered right to your door.

Since the pellets are tiny, about 1 inch long, they burn more efficiently than wood. By creating much less ash and creosote. Creosote is known to cause blackening of the mirrors and chimney fires.

The fire that is created by pellet stove is relatively concentrated in the center, and if you buy a modern pellet stove with glass at its front, you can enjoy watching it burn. But be careful, the fire is intensely hot because it is more efficiently produced.

Now how do you know if you have found the best pellet stove for yourself? Well, the first thing you need to look at, it the hopper. It should have a large hopper which can hold at least 50 pounds of the pellet in one go so that you don't have to keep refilling it. If you ignore this and decide to go for a small hopper one, then you may need to fill it more than once a day.

For you to determine which is the best one, you will need to keep the following factors in mind.

Top Pellet Stoves Comparison

NameItem WeightDimensions 
Pleasant Hearth
Cabinet Style
(Editor’s Choice)
235 pounds31 x 30 x 43.8 inches Check Price
US Stove R5824 209 pounds21.5 x 33.5 x 20 inches Check Price
Castle 12327 Serenity
(Editor’s Choice)
186 pounds 23.8 x 18.5 x 34 inches Check Price
Comfortbilt HP22-
50,000 BTU
Check Price
Pelpro Pellet Stove 22.8 x 24.5 x 36.5 inches Check Price
Pleasant Hearth
Medium 35000 BTU's
195 pounds31 x 30 x 43.8 inches Check Price

Cost

Unlike the wood stoves, you don't need a chimney for them, only requiring a ventilation pipe. It makes it easier for the pellet stoves to be installed where ever you like in the room. The installation is easier for pellet stoves.

The standard price range is $1500-3500 for pellet stoves.

Another factor which would influence the overall cost of pellet stoves would be the raw material you are using as fuel. Most people would want to use hardwood pellets as these are most efficient and produce the maximum amount of heat. But these are expensive. You can use other materials such as sawdust to keep the cost low, but you must ensure that it will not clog up your stove. You obviously have to consider the availability of the raw material as well so you can come up with an estimate for your heating.

Size and Dimensions

Pellet stoves are ranked per heating capacity they have which is known as heat output range, and this must be between 10,000-40,000 for a decent pellet stove. Anything lower than that will not heat up your house properly. The efficiency value should be between 75-90% and not less than that.

The other factor to consider is how big your house is and what is the layout. What kind of insulation does your home has and if you are using the pellet stove as a primary means of heating your home or not.

Kind of Fuel

If you are living in the state of New York than a standard size bag of pellets will cost you around $8, and this is going to get consumed in 10 hours.

So it is important that you keep in mind what type of raw material is readily available because it will influence your choice of buying a pellet stove.

Ensure that you have access to a good grade of pellets locally and if you realize that the annual expense will be high then do consider a multi-fuel pellet stove.

Maintenance of Pellet Stoves

Pellet stoves will require regular checking and maintenance because their small parts will need cleaning. You don't want anything to clog up your stove as this will damage it. Our pellet stove review below will give you an insight into different models. You can see their pictures and look for one that is easier to clean.

Some suppliers offer an annual professional cleaning service which is very useful and takes the stress out of finding someone to clean your pellet stove. All pellet stoves do not require professional cleaning. Some designs are relatively easy to clean. You can just use an external rod and clean the inside with it.

However, you need to remember that you must dispose of the ashes at least once a week. Some models come with an ash drawer which is easy to take out and clean.

Like I mentioned earlier, a big size hopper will save you the hassle of filling it again and again. It should have a capacity of about 35-130 pounds ideally. But the ultimate decision lies with your heating requirements.

To maintain your pellet stove, you just should follow the manufacturer's recommendations. And it could be quite simple as just checking if the motor and fans are in working order or not and removing ashes. It is a rather simple process and is not expensive at all.

But if your pellet stove requires a professional service than finding someone can be hard, and you certainly cannot repair the motors or circuit board yourself.

Top Feed or Bottom

There are two varieties of pellet stoves. Either they have a chute at the top, or the pellets are fed from behind or side of the burn box.

A top fed stove is more prone to have its burn box clogged with clinkers. That is why the seller emphasizes that you only buy high-grade pellets, so there are less ash and lesser chances of clogging.

The bottom or side fed models don't have this problem because the ash is pushed into the ash drawer. Hence the need for premium fuel is reduced. Check out our top-rated pellet stove reviews to decide which one is for you.

 top rated pellet stove reviews.jpg
  • DESIGN OF PELLET STOVE

  • Quality

  • Backup Power

  • Pellet Stove Safety

Wood stoves can put your house at risk and cause a fire. Whereas pellet stoves are safer and they burn cleaner. So you know, your home is not at risk. The flames are contained and prevent users from getting accidental burns from flying embers.t

It is recommended that you take added precaution to keep children and pets away from them as they are boiling to touch.

Some additional features to consider with pellet stoves are automatic clean up, faux logs and windows to give a modern finish to the stove. Keep all of these things in mind Consider all these key points, and you’ll be able to find the best pellet stove for your home.


What Are the Advantages of Using Best Pellet Stoves?​​​​​


  • The biggest advantage which homeowners will witness is the massive reduction in their energy bills, especially during the winter season. They can enjoy having a warm home without paying high energy bills. After installing an efficient pellet stove, many have seen a cost reduction by 50% in the first years and some saying they saved up to 67%. So the break even point for pellet stoves is about 24 months. In simple terms, pellet stoves will recover their cost in two years of operation.
  • The second most significant advantage is the conservation of nature mainly existing forest and trees are saved from cutting down. Wood stoves need wood to function which means trees have to be cut down. But pellet stoves are environment-friendly. Pellet stove utilize compressed garbage materials for fuel hence helping in reducing waste and preserving trees and forests.
  • The last advantage is that pellet stoves produce heat for a long time after one filling of the hopper. It allows you to heat up your home for upto72 hours before requiring you to refill the hopper. You don't have to worry about going out to find wood during coldest of days. And imagine the convenience that comes with remote thermostat control and electronic ignition. You will have an investment that will pay off itself quickly and save you from future costs.

Is Burning Pellets Bad for the Environment?

Well, the answer to this question lies somewhere between Yes and No. The new designs of pellet stoves allow more than 92% of the pellets to two into energy. They are clean-burning meaning that they leave little to no residue behind.

However, if your stove is old and if you are still using a wood stove, then chances are it does not use clean-burning technology and probably gives out a lot of black smoke from your chimney. It is poisonous to the environment.

The latest technology used in the best pellet stoves is extremely environment-friendly and some countries such as Norway, have the government programs in place so they can assist people to replace their old stoves with new ones. In the United States, homeowners get a green tax credit up to 30% the price of their stove, but it should have an efficiency rating of 75% and higher.

WOOD STOVE VS. PELLET STOVE

There is something emotionally satisfying about watching the fire in your stove be it wood or pellet. It is kind of mesmerizing to see, and both wood and pellet stoves are an attractive choice for your heating needs. Now we look at the comparison between two and assess which is better.

  • While wood stoves are aesthetically pleasing to look at, pellet stoves are more efficient and burn cleaner. There is little to no residue, and they come with ash drawers which can be cleaned out quickly. Wood stoves will provide you with a traditional fire but they will need a chimney and will produce a lot of black smoke.
  • Wood stoves will also require a constant addition of fuel (wood) into it, and if you don’t have enough especially during cold winter nights, it will be a hassle to go out and look for them. Pellet stoves with a good size hopper can burn for up to 72 hours after being filled with pellets.
  • ​Pellet stoves require electricity whereas wood stove is not dependent on electricity at all.
  • Pellet stove use compressed waste materials as fuel which is healthier for the environment otherwise these will become landfill. Wood stove, on the other hand, will need cutting down of trees. And you will require more wood to produce the same amount of heat as compared to burning pellets.
  • Wood stoves are more prone to fires because of the residue burning wood leaves behind.

Keeping in mind all the above points, it becomes clear that choosing a pellet stove will be a wise choice. It is eco-friendlier and at the same time more efficient. It will produce more heat and reduce your energy bills.

What Else Do I Need to Know?

Stove whether wood or pellet will require maintenance. You must keep it clean for it to give optimum performance. You can either clean the stove yourself or ask the supplier to provide you cleaning services.

The most convenient option would be a fireplace insert rather than a freestanding stove. The reason for this is you don’t need any construction. To run the pipe through it, you will need to drill a hole. On the other hand, the freestanding stove will have to be vented through your roof or horizontally through a wall.

How Much Will You Save With Pellets?

Depending on where you live, an average cord of wood will cost you $200+=. Now, this is the same amount of money you will need to spend to buy a ton of pellets.

The wood will take up space, and if you decide to buy them in bulk, you will need to have enough storage space for them.

One ton of pellets, on the other hand, come in 40-pound bags which can be stored around the house easily.

You should buy pellets which are available locally to you otherwise shipping cost can eliminate the saving you are hoping to have.

Top Rated Pallet Stove Reviews

Now let us have a look at some of the best pellet stoves which are available in the market. We have reviewed each pellet stove regarding its size, design, heating capacity and functionality.

We are going to discuss a bit about their pros and cons, and once you have read them all, we will give you a conclusion. So, you can decide which pellet stove fits your requirements. We are also providing links to individual pellets where you can read customer reviews and also check their availability and buy them at discounted prices.

Castle Serenity Wood Pellet Stove

The Castle Serenity pellet stove is a delight to look at. It will not only light up your room but also provide efficient heating like no other pellet stove does. It has a sleek and modern design, and that’s not all, it comes with a smart controlling mechanism. The controller allows you to heat your home on a schedule. You can customize the schedule according to your liking and need. And you will always have another option of controlling it manually if you wish. You can set the thermostat and put it on a weekly operational mode. Your home will never be cold even in freezing temperatures.

Advice to the wise, always keep your children away especially young ones as pellet stoves tend to get burning hot. And when setting this up yourself, keep in mind that it does contain some small parts that a child may be tempted to put in their mouth.

Castle Serenity Wood Pellet Stove.jpg

PROS

Thermal efficiency is more than 70% for this stove.

It is EPA certified.

It has automatic ignition and five feed rates.

It can heat up 1500 square feet home efficiently.

CONS

Compared to other pellet stoves, it is quite affordable.

Pleasant Hearth Cabinet Style

A pleasant looking pellet stove indeed! It weighs less than 200 pounds and comes with five unique heat settings. You can either run this stove to produce continuous heat or on a maximum and minimum setting. It has an iron cast door which is heavy, so kids don’t open it up easily. It comes with a five-year warranty for your peace of mind. It has a unique system of comfort control incorporated in its design. It will certainly make your living room come to life!

PROS

It has a heating capacity of 50,000 BTU and can warm up an average 1200 feet house.

It can burn for 6-8 hours in one fuelling.

Fits 6-inch stove pipe, a push/pull draft control level under ash lip, and a variable speed blower included

It is Omni tested, and EPA certified.

It is a non-catalytic wood burning stove.

Approved for mobile home use with an air intake kit sold separately

It is quite a beast as it weighs more than the Castle Serenity Wood Pellet Stove at 277 pounds.

It has an 18-inch log capacity.

CONS

It is an expensive investment which needs careful consideration.

It can be noisy because of the motor.

Comfortbilt Pellet Stove HP22

The Comfortbilt Pellet Stove comes with a unique feature. It has a digital thermostat controller. You can adjust the heating levels of your home with one touch. You will not need to worry about keeping this stove firing with a bed of coal because it has an electric ignition process. You can set the temperature and timing according to your heating requirements, and it will automatically turn on and heat your home. You will always receive the right amount of heating with this unit because the blower is also automated.

PROS

It has a heating capacity of 50,000 BTU and can heat up a large home - up to 2,000 square feet!

Large viewing area and is available in Bay Design.

It has a programmable thermostat, automatic ignition and comes with an ash pan and55 lbs. Hopper capacity.

It is EPA certified and made in the US.

It has a thermal efficiency of 86%

It has five blower speeds and is fully automatic.

1 Year Parts Warranty-Technical assistance available after purchase

CONS

The flame produces by this pellet stove is smaller than what wood would produce.

It does not give the look of real fire.

US Stove R5824 Pellet Stove

Although this stove looks very compact but doesn't be fooled, you can load up to 55 pounds of pellets in it at one time. That is enough to heat your home for a whole day. You don’t have to keep adding more pellets after few hours with this design. It has a circulation blower that optimizes the temperature controls, so you only need to fill the hopper once per day to get even heating. The blower can connect with any standard thermostat and operates at 200 CFM. It is a multi-fuelled stove and will burn most types of pellets that you can find in your community. For this design, the wood pellets will work best because the smoke from them is minimised. Biomass pellets may also work reasonably well, but higher smoke output makes it difficult to ventilate the exhaust of the stove fully.

PROS

It is a very compact design so that it will take smaller space in your room.

It has a modern look which will blend in with most home interiors.

It can heat up to 20 hours at a time.

It has a large window to view, made of air wash glass.

CONS

The inbuilt motor system needs electricity to operate.

In case of power shortage, you won’t have any heating too.

Click here to view prices on Amazon and get a great deal on this stove.

Pelpro Pellet Stove

The Pelpro Pellet Stove is the biggest one we are reviewing. It looks neat and has a glass window so you can see the fire. Its door is made of solid cast iron and has a handle to open with ease. It has the biggest hopper out there and can provide heating for more than 72 hours at a time. You can just fill it once and sit back and relax for a whole week. It is extremely efficient, more than all the designs mentioned so far. So your energy bill will be cut by 50-65% in the first year for sure.

PROS

It can heat a large home of up to 2200 square feet

It has a thermal efficiency of 85% more than any other design.

It provides extended burning time up to 80 hours after one fuelling.

It has three heat settings

CONS

It has an extra-large hopper about 130 lbs, so it will take up more space in your room.

It is high priced.

It is available on Amazon, and you can check out the reviews here.

Pleasant Hearth Medium Pellet Stove with 40-Pound Hopper

This is another pellet stove from Pleasant Hearth range. We reviewed the cabinet style one above. This one is bulkier, it would take up more space, but because of its large hopper, it will give you a burning time of 12-24 hours, which is more than the cabinet style one. It has far more superior efficiency rating too. It has automatic ignition and five heat settings.

PROS

It covers a heating area of up to 1750 square feet

It is a 35000 BTU and a 40-pound hopper.

It includes an air kit and a blower for which some assembly is required.

It is also EPA Certified with 85% efficiency rating

It has an 'exclusive' Comfort Control System which allows you to heat your home continuously on MIN or MAX temperature settings.

CONS

It is a very heavy model.

It will take up considerable space in your living room.

Click here to view prices on Amazon and get a great deal on this stove.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much money can I save on my energy bills by using pellet stove?

Are wood stoves as good as pellet stoves?

How long will a good pellet stove last?

CONCLUSION

Today we have talked all about pellet stoves, what they are? How they perform? How they compare with wood stoves? Which are the best pellet stoves of 2017? And we discussed a comprehensive list of things you should keep in mind when buying a new pellet stove for yourself and your family. Then we shared pellet stoves reviews, and now we will decide which one is the best out of all these.

We have a clear winner which is the Comfortbilt Pellet Stove. This stove not only covers a huge area of up to 2000 feet but it also comes with a large hopper of 55 lbs. You will save yourself from filling it again and again because of the extra capacity of its hopper. The blower is automatic, and it has an electric ignition process. The blower comes in 5-speed settings which are ideal for varying degree of cold during the winter months.

The design is not only aesthetically pleasing, but it also comes in a bay design in two different colors, green and gray. You don’t need a chimney, and it will not produce black smoke. It is so efficient that there will be no residue and if there happens to be any, then you can just throw it out by removing the ash tray at the bottom and cleaning it.

You can be sure that your money is invested in the right pellet stove because this will save you 65% on your energy bill during the first and up to 75% of your second year of usage. You can be sure that this pellet stove will recover its price within the first two years!

So what are you waiting for click here and buy it now!

Let us know about this pellet stove review  via comment section.


Related Buyer's Guide

About the Author ReviewerTouch

ReviewerTouch is a team that provides 100% real reviews for their visitors.We have 20 professional members to research well, provide Reviews and buyer's guide.Read more

follow me on:

Leave a Comment: